I’ve been dreading writing a blog about this episode. And yet, this is such a good episode – it checks all those Buffy boxes (humor, drama, romance, unexpected twist, and plenty of life lessons).
A week before the originally scheduled air date of this episode something horrible happened: Columbine. That one word says it all, and yet it shouldn’t. Columbine is a type of flower, it’s a town, it’s a high school. And it also sums of the following words: the shooting at Columbine High School. The world changed, and I didn’t even realize at the time how much it did so. As an adult this horrible event makes me want to cry. As a teacher I’ve been through so many drills on what to do if there’s ever a mass shooter in a school. These things weren’t part of my student experience in the 1990s. Columbine, along with 9/11, completely changed the world and how students experience high school and the world. While I’m very grateful to have had my high school experience before these events were felt (I was in 11th grade for Columbine, in college for 9/11), I realize now that I can’t even imagine what it must like to be a high schooler now. In 20 years things have changed, and not because of various trends, but because of tragedies.
Buffy not airing “Earshot” made me really angry. It made Sarah Michelle Gellar angry, too. I remember both Joss Whedon and Seth Green, when interviewed, seemed to take it more in stride, their reactions were more compassionate. “Earshot” was only the first episode to be affected by the mass shooting. “Graduation Day Part 2” didn’t air until August, same as “Earshot” (or maybe one of them actually aired in September – I don’t remember the exact dates anymore), because the plot involved high school students taking up arms at graduation. This also made me angry – obviously they were taking up arms to fight evil, not to gun down their fellow students.
When the episode finally aired I remember thinking that Sarah Michelle Gellar was right – the episode was nothing like Columbine and actually centered around a suicide. Well, and an angry lunch lady with access to rat poison. How could The WB have pulled this episode? This episode may have helped us after Columbine. Now, as an adult I understand the decision that was made with both episodes. I’m not angry anymore – not about this at any rate.
Now I’m angry that the violence hasn’t stopped. At one point in the episode Cordelia and Oz are discussing school shootings, commenting that high school shootings are now trendy. I don’t remember a school shooting before Columbine. I know they happened, but I don’t remember when I found out that Columbine wasn’t the first. That conversation now is chilling. It seems timelier today than it did back in 1999. Not only are there more shootings in high schools, but in elementary schools – no one is safe from violence in this day and age. I don’t even want to think about the events of this magnitude that have taken place outside of a school building.
And so, writing this blog, 20 years later, is not easy. There are so many emotions tied up in it that have almost nothing whatsoever to do with the episode itself. I can’t watch this episode without thinking about Columbine. For a few years after I was able to pretend that I wasn’t thinking about Columbine, but then violence ramped up again and it hasn’t stopped.
As a result, this episode is almost a gem. You couldn’t even conceive of writing an episode like this today. And again, it isn’t even really about a mass shooting, but that is how this episode will always be perceived. Normally I would say something like, “and that’s the real tragedy,” but obviously it’s not. This episode is more of a casualty, a never-ending reminder that evil exists and it effects everyone, even if it is in small, seemingly unimportant, ways.
Okay, so now that I’ve bummed everyone out I’ll talk about the episode itself, as there are some really important things that happen. For starters, there are still ramifications from the previous episode, “Enemies,” and Angel’s charade. As Buffy and her classmates study Othello in their English class (yay for more Shakespeare!), we see that Buffy is still trying to wrap her head around Faith’s sort-of Iago-y turn (I mean, their story doesn’t quite fit the bill, but it’s just similar enough for Buffy to be able to relate to the story – just as Cordelia could relate to The Merchant of Venice back in season 1).
Here, the plots all get wrapped up together. As Buffy gains her aspect of the demon (more on that in a second), she’s able to hear everyone’s thoughts and hopes to hear Angel’s – to help reassure her that Angel does love her and is sorry about what happened. Then, as we hear Buffy explain in class that Iago is a dark reflection of Othello, we hear Angel explain that like a mirror, his thoughts have no reflection, meaning that Buffy can’t hear them. What can she hear though? A shadowy voice claiming that it will kill all the students tomorrow (I could clearly tell that it was a female voice, but Buffy was probably too caught up in all the thoughts to be able to hear gender clearly).
So let’s rewind. Buffy kills a demon and gets some blood on her that will give her an aspect of a demon. The demon has no mouth, so in retrospect, it makes perfect sense that she would get telepathy, but that aspect could be anything. Leading Willow to ask if it was a boy demon. And you thought all Buffy had to worry about were horns!
And so, she can hear thoughts, which at first is pretty neat, until she realizes that she can’t turn it off or control it. It’s actually pretty amusing for her to hear all her friends’ thoughts before the whole insanity thing happens. Cordelia says what she thinks, Xander can’t keep his mind off of sex, and Oz is afraid that if Buffy can hear his thoughts he might stop being him (in a very Oz-like philosophical manner), leading Willow to be jealous that Buffy can hear the thoughts of her reticent boyfriend.
In the midst of all this, Buffy hears the mystery voice threatening murder, but is confined to her bed while Giles and Angel come up with a cure for her. In the meantime, her friends all go around the school interviewing teachers and students, hoping to find out who is planning to kill all the students. Xander makes a crack about it being the lunch lady, having no idea how right he is. Willow is assigned to Jonathan – again! Xander has another heart to heart with Larry, and we finally see Nancy in the non “Wish” world. She is not nice in this world at all. Her white hat persona is a much better person.
As it turns out, Xander ends up saving the day when he goes into the lunchroom to get an extra pudding (or was it jello) and sees the lunch lady putting rat poison in the food. He screams at everyone in the lunch room and turns over everyone’s food, thwarting the evil lunch lady.
Buffy is cured just in time to go to the clock tower at the school (has this always existed?) and stop the person with a rifle. This is the heart of the story. Jonathan has a rifle and Buffy makes a beautiful speech explaining why Jonathan shouldn’t shoot everyone. She explains that everyone has pain – you just can’t always see it. Jonathan then explains that he brought the rifle to school only to shoot himself. (Why a rifle? How would you fatally shoot yourself with a long pointy gun?) Here is the twist and the reason that this episode is not at all like Columbine. Here is the reason why airing this episode would have helped heal the nation, but I digress (I promise I’m over it – I just can’t forget how I felt). Jonathan, a recurring character, suddenly becomes a real person. He knows he’s a loser and is hurt and unwilling to go on until Buffy saves his life by convincing him not to commit suicide.
We could all stand to learn a few things from Buffy.
There were a couple of things from this episode that I thought were worth noting: we see cheerleader Cordelia again, it’s been a while, and Angel makes a joke. He does this very rarely on BtVS, but is actually pretty funny on his spin-off. We get a little sneak peek of what’s to come.
Now while Buffy was home and incapacitated, she discovered a secret of her mother’s from “Band Candy.” You remember that time that Joyce and Giles had sex, right? Well, Joyce had a little trouble hiding certain thoughts from her daughter leading to this wonderful moment at the very, very end of the episode. As Buffy and Giles walk together, Buffy adds, “if you’re not too busy having sex with my mother.” The shock of this sends him straight into a tree. It’s so funny! And such a Buffy ending. And that is the ending I will leave you with as well.
Addendum: As wonderful as this episode is I decided not to add pictures out of respect for the seriousness of the topic it raises.